Rank213 / 213c 第五轮:真实成本下利润厚度

对象:rank213_age90_14d_skip1d_voladj / 213c family。样本使用 monthly-volume causal universe、age≥90d、daily next-day hold,不重新下载行情。

生成时间:2026-05-07 05:37:32 UTC。成本表统一为 cost_bps_per_1x_turnover,覆盖 4/8/12/16bps;funding 只做 sensitivity,不计作真实收益。

Rank213 版本总览 · Top50 4x4 第四轮扩展 · 第四轮归因

结论

第五轮没有找到可以直接 Pass 的候选。 基准 daily short_every_day 在 12bps/1x turnover 后为 -2.19 bps,累计 -66.53%,最大回撤 -84.08%。它说明第四轮 flat 12bps 的表观余量,落到换手成本口径后并不够厚。

唯一 Watch 是 rank_buffer_extra_8:12bps 后日均 4.11 bps,累计 52.78%,换手 0.210x/day,但最大回撤仍有 -48.88%,不能作为放大 notional 的依据。

本轮最有用的方向是:rank buffer / 慢 rebalance / 持仓 carry 这类低换手结构。short gate 能改善部分均值,但回撤没有被压住;prior30 dispersion 仍更适合解释和监控,不适合作为主交易开关。

给新研究者的读法

核心读数

-2.19 bps基准 12bps 日均
4.11 bps唯一 Watch 12bps 日均
0.210x唯一 Watch 平均换手
0 / 1 / 31Pass / Watch / Fail

12bps 候选筛选

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysreason
Watchturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_84.11 bps52.78%-48.88%0.3680.2102257positive at 12bps, but drawdown/turnover still needs execution proof
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_7d4.56 bps68.05%-66.11%0.4050.2002257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gatebtc_prior7_positive3.40 bps-7.74%-72.77%0.2370.5011203does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma202.98 bps-17.76%-77.30%0.2050.4751197does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_high1.61 bps-38.31%-86.99%0.1130.385756does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_2d1.06 bps-28.67%-63.68%0.0890.4062257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Faildynamic_universestatic_top300.40 bps-34.19%-51.23%0.0360.5282257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_negative0.35 bps-46.22%-90.39%0.0270.4881075does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantretvol_21d_skip1d0.02 bps-43.73%-79.24%0.0020.5012257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_2-0.39 bps-47.80%-76.84%-0.0330.3852257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_3d-0.74 bps-52.44%-69.64%-0.0630.3252257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_positive-1.03 bps-66.82%-89.78%-0.0720.4931177does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_mid_high-1.07 bps-63.31%-84.60%-0.0790.4951510does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateeligible_ew_above_ma20-1.21 bps-68.18%-87.96%-0.0840.4561083does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gatebtc_prior30_positive-1.37 bps-68.65%-83.56%-0.0960.4691217does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_1_per_side-1.43 bps-58.83%-77.20%-0.1230.4192257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma50-1.44 bps-69.20%-83.81%-0.1010.4581216does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_4-1.67 bps-60.02%-78.05%-0.1470.2922257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Faildynamic_universestatic_top20-1.91 bps-60.93%-77.61%-0.1740.4782257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_2_per_side-2.16 bps-65.96%-82.81%-0.1810.5722257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateshort_every_day-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.5982257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantretvol_14d_skip1d-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.5982257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Faildynamic_universestatic_top50-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.5982257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantrank_ensemble_7_14_21-2.56 bps-68.90%-92.10%-0.2160.6352257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateeligible_ew_above_ma50-3.01 bps-78.45%-91.09%-0.2110.423983does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Faildynamic_universeprior30_dispersion_low20_mid50_high80-3.13 bps-73.44%-88.45%-0.2580.5942257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantdownside_vol_14d_skip1d-3.25 bps-73.82%-88.94%-0.2710.5922257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gatebtc_prior7_negative-4.10 bps-80.70%-96.43%-0.3130.4871044does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Faildynamic_universestatic_top80-4.16 bps-81.13%-94.32%-0.3140.6422257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failshort_gateeligible_prior30_positive-4.40 bps-84.33%-90.24%-0.3080.4361015does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantretvol_7d_skip1d-5.97 bps-85.66%-93.08%-0.5060.8142257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover
Failsignal_variantraw_return_14d_skip1d-8.90 bps-93.78%-95.14%-0.6690.5572257does not clear positive 12bps net with acceptable drawdown/turnover

筛选规则偏保守:必须在 12bps 后为正,同时回撤和换手不能太差;funding sensitivity 不参与真实候选排序。

12bps 全部实验 Top 24

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysgross_mean_bpslong_half_mean_bpsshort_half_mean_bps
Watchturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_84.11 bps52.78%-48.88%0.3680.21022576.62 bps5.50 bps1.13 bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_7d4.56 bps68.05%-66.11%0.4050.20022576.97 bps6.29 bps0.67 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_prior7_positive3.40 bps-7.74%-72.77%0.2370.50112039.42 bps6.10 bps3.31 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma202.98 bps-17.76%-77.30%0.2050.47511978.68 bps6.10 bps2.58 bps
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_high1.61 bps-38.31%-86.99%0.1130.3857566.24 bps6.10 bps0.14 bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_2d1.06 bps-28.67%-63.68%0.0890.40622575.92 bps5.75 bps0.17 bps
Faildynamic_universestatic_top300.40 bps-34.19%-51.23%0.0360.52822576.73 bps5.86 bps0.87 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_negative0.35 bps-46.22%-90.39%0.0270.48810756.20 bps6.10 bps0.10 bps
Failsignal_variantretvol_21d_skip1d0.02 bps-43.73%-79.24%0.0020.50122576.04 bps6.74 bps-0.70 bps
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_2-0.39 bps-47.80%-76.84%-0.0330.38522574.23 bps3.33 bps0.90 bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_3d-0.74 bps-52.44%-69.64%-0.0630.32522573.16 bps6.86 bps-3.70 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_positive-1.03 bps-66.82%-89.78%-0.0720.49311774.88 bps6.10 bps-1.22 bps
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_mid_high-1.07 bps-63.31%-84.60%-0.0790.49515104.87 bps6.10 bps-1.23 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_ew_above_ma20-1.21 bps-68.18%-87.96%-0.0840.45610834.26 bps6.10 bps-1.84 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_prior30_positive-1.37 bps-68.65%-83.56%-0.0960.46912174.26 bps6.10 bps-1.84 bps
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_1_per_side-1.43 bps-58.83%-77.20%-0.1230.41922573.59 bps4.88 bps-1.29 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma50-1.44 bps-69.20%-83.81%-0.1010.45812164.05 bps6.10 bps-2.05 bps
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_4-1.67 bps-60.02%-78.05%-0.1470.29222571.83 bps2.46 bps-0.64 bps
Faildynamic_universestatic_top20-1.91 bps-60.93%-77.61%-0.1740.47822573.83 bps5.36 bps-1.53 bps
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_2_per_side-2.16 bps-65.96%-82.81%-0.1810.57222574.71 bps5.95 bps-1.24 bps
Failshort_gateshort_every_day-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps
Failsignal_variantretvol_14d_skip1d-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps
Faildynamic_universestatic_top50-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps
Failsignal_variantrank_ensemble_7_14_21-2.56 bps-68.90%-92.10%-0.2160.63522575.06 bps5.66 bps-0.60 bps

Short Leg 条件化

long half 每天保留;short gate OFF 时 short half 空仓。表中 active_short_days 是实际做空天数。

最好的 short gate 是 btc_prior7_positive:active short days 1203,short half 日均 3.31 bps,12bps 后组合日均 3.40 bps,但累计仍为 -7.74%、最大回撤 -72.77%。推论是:short 条件化能减少坏 short,但它没有解决组合路径风险。

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysgross_mean_bpslong_half_mean_bpsshort_half_mean_bps
Failshort_gatebtc_prior7_positive3.40 bps-7.74%-72.77%0.2370.50112039.42 bps6.10 bps3.31 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma202.98 bps-17.76%-77.30%0.2050.47511978.68 bps6.10 bps2.58 bps
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_high1.61 bps-38.31%-86.99%0.1130.3857566.24 bps6.10 bps0.14 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_negative0.35 bps-46.22%-90.39%0.0270.48810756.20 bps6.10 bps0.10 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_prior7_positive-1.03 bps-66.82%-89.78%-0.0720.49311774.88 bps6.10 bps-1.22 bps
Failshort_gateprior30_dispersion_mid_high-1.07 bps-63.31%-84.60%-0.0790.49515104.87 bps6.10 bps-1.23 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_ew_above_ma20-1.21 bps-68.18%-87.96%-0.0840.45610834.26 bps6.10 bps-1.84 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_prior30_positive-1.37 bps-68.65%-83.56%-0.0960.46912174.26 bps6.10 bps-1.84 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_above_ma50-1.44 bps-69.20%-83.81%-0.1010.45812164.05 bps6.10 bps-2.05 bps
Failshort_gateshort_every_day-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_ew_above_ma50-3.01 bps-78.45%-91.09%-0.2110.4239832.06 bps6.10 bps-4.04 bps
Failshort_gatebtc_prior7_negative-4.10 bps-80.70%-96.43%-0.3130.48710441.75 bps6.10 bps-4.35 bps
Failshort_gateeligible_prior30_positive-4.40 bps-84.33%-90.24%-0.3080.43610150.83 bps6.10 bps-5.27 bps

降换手增厚

这组是本轮唯一有正向可用信息的方向。最强均值来自 rebalance_every_7d,12bps 后 4.56 bps,平均换手 0.200x/day;但它最大回撤 -66.11%。唯一 Watch 的 rank_buffer_extra_8 稍弱但回撤更低,说明“少换一点、让持仓有惯性”比“每天完全追 rank”更接近真实成本下可活的形态。

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysgross_mean_bpslong_half_mean_bpsshort_half_mean_bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_7d4.56 bps68.05%-66.11%0.4050.20022576.97 bps6.29 bps0.67 bps
Watchturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_84.11 bps52.78%-48.88%0.3680.21022576.62 bps5.50 bps1.13 bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_2d1.06 bps-28.67%-63.68%0.0890.40622575.92 bps5.75 bps0.17 bps
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_2-0.39 bps-47.80%-76.84%-0.0330.38522574.23 bps3.33 bps0.90 bps
Failturnover_reductionrebalance_every_3d-0.74 bps-52.44%-69.64%-0.0630.32522573.16 bps6.86 bps-3.70 bps
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_1_per_side-1.43 bps-58.83%-77.20%-0.1230.41922573.59 bps4.88 bps-1.29 bps
Failturnover_reductionrank_buffer_extra_4-1.67 bps-60.02%-78.05%-0.1470.29222571.83 bps2.46 bps-0.64 bps
Failturnover_reductionreplacement_cap_2_per_side-2.16 bps-65.96%-82.81%-0.1810.57222574.71 bps5.95 bps-1.24 bps

信号小范围优化

信号微调没有稳定增厚。最好的 retvol_21d_skip1d 在 12bps 后只有 0.02 bps,其余 7d、ensemble、downside vol、raw return 都更差。推论是:当前问题不是再找一个更锋利的 return-vol 变体,而是成本、换手和 short-leg 结构。

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysgross_mean_bpslong_half_mean_bpsshort_half_mean_bps
Failsignal_variantretvol_21d_skip1d0.02 bps-43.73%-79.24%0.0020.50122576.04 bps6.74 bps-0.70 bps
Failsignal_variantretvol_14d_skip1d-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps
Failsignal_variantrank_ensemble_7_14_21-2.56 bps-68.90%-92.10%-0.2160.63522575.06 bps5.66 bps-0.60 bps
Failsignal_variantdownside_vol_14d_skip1d-3.25 bps-73.82%-88.94%-0.2710.59222573.85 bps5.25 bps-1.39 bps
Failsignal_variantretvol_7d_skip1d-5.97 bps-85.66%-93.08%-0.5060.81422573.80 bps4.10 bps-0.30 bps
Failsignal_variantraw_return_14d_skip1d-8.90 bps-93.78%-95.14%-0.6690.5572257-2.22 bps1.05 bps-3.26 bps

Dynamic Universe

静态 static_top30 是 universe 组里最不差的版本,12bps 后 0.40 bps、最大回撤 -51.23%。Top80 和 dispersion-driven low20/mid50/high80 都更差,说明扩大池子不是免费增厚,容易把小币暴露和 short 噪声一起放大。

verdictexperiment_groupvariantnet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_daysgross_mean_bpslong_half_mean_bpsshort_half_mean_bpsavg_universe_sizeavg_eligible_count
Faildynamic_universestatic_top300.40 bps-34.19%-51.23%0.0360.52822576.73 bps5.86 bps0.87 bps30.00024.933
Faildynamic_universestatic_top20-1.91 bps-60.93%-77.61%-0.1740.47822573.83 bps5.36 bps-1.53 bps20.00016.875
Faildynamic_universestatic_top50-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.59822574.98 bps6.10 bps-1.12 bps50.00040.161
Faildynamic_universeprior30_dispersion_low20_mid50_high80-3.13 bps-73.44%-88.45%-0.2580.59422573.99 bps5.72 bps-1.73 bps50.00038.127
Faildynamic_universestatic_top80-4.16 bps-81.13%-94.32%-0.3140.64222573.55 bps5.01 bps-1.46 bps80.00060.378

Funding Sensitivity

没有在当前 monthly-volume age90 Top50 逐日样本里发现可直接对齐每条 short leg 的完整 funding 序列;本节只把 short active day 加 0/+1/+2/+3bps/day 做敏感性,不作为真实 PnL。即使 +3bps/day,12bps 后也只有 0.77 bps,累计仍为 -34.09%,因此 funding 不能被当作这轮 cover 12bps 的主答案。

variantcost_bps_per_1x_turnoverfunding_credit_bps_per_short_active_daynet_mean_bpsnet_cum_pctmax_drawdown_pctsharpeavg_turnover_xactive_short_days
short_every_day4.0000.0002.59 bps-0.02%-70.30%0.2160.5982257
short_every_day8.0000.0000.20 bps-42.15%-78.25%0.0170.5982257
short_every_day12.0000.000-2.19 bps-66.53%-84.08%-0.1830.5982257
short_every_day16.0000.000-4.58 bps-80.64%-88.43%-0.3820.5982257
short_every_day4.0001.0003.58 bps25.30%-66.40%0.2990.5982257
short_every_day8.0001.0001.19 bps-27.49%-75.40%0.0990.5982257
short_every_day12.0001.000-1.20 bps-58.05%-81.99%-0.1010.5982257
short_every_day16.0001.000-3.60 bps-75.73%-86.81%-0.3000.5982257
short_every_day4.0002.0004.57 bps57.02%-61.99%0.3810.5982257
short_every_day8.0002.0002.17 bps-9.12%-72.17%0.1810.5982257
short_every_day12.0002.000-0.22 bps-47.42%-79.62%-0.0180.5982257
short_every_day16.0002.000-2.61 bps-69.58%-85.08%-0.2180.5982257
short_every_day4.0003.0005.55 bps96.78%-57.00%0.4630.5982257
short_every_day8.0003.0003.16 bps13.89%-68.51%0.2640.5982257
short_every_day12.0003.0000.77 bps-34.09%-76.95%0.0640.5982257
short_every_day16.0003.000-1.62 bps-61.87%-83.12%-0.1350.5982257

推论与操作建议

产物